Create account
Cover of Supernatural

Similar games

Games like Supernatural

2024PC62 % positive8.79 €

You step into the shoes of detective Wyatt, who searches a haunted house for a missing housemaid. Its appeal lies in the creeping atmosphere, where you piece together clues and treat every shadow with suspicion.

  • Dread and tension
  • Dark, serious atmosphere
  • Strong, story-driven narrative
＋ Combine with my games

Where to buy

* Affiliate link. Prices are synced regularly and may have changed in the shop since.

More in these topics: Horror games Detective games

In short: Games like Supernatural

Each of these 10 games shares something of what makes Supernatural special. The reasons are listed right on each game.

Similar in what way?

0 of 3

Up to three areas count more, the rest steps back.

Not for me Exclude horror, turn-based combat, pixel art …

Games where this is clearly part of it are left out, no matter how well the rest fits.

Horror Turn-based combat High difficulty Roguelike runs Shooter Pixel art Grind Survival PvP Open world Card game

10 games with a similar feel, sorted by match · How is this calculated?

Show games from the same series

Best match

Fears to Fathom: Carson House

92 %Match

2023PC, Steam Deck playable91 % positive4.99 €

Brings what grabs you about Supernatural: dread and tension, a dark atmosphere as well as a strong story.

A short first-person horror game where you play house-sitter Noah spending a weekend in an eerie mansion as the threat slowly escalates. Tension comes from atmosphere, mundane tasks turning sinister, and sudden scares.

Where to buy

* Affiliate link. Prices are synced regularly and may have changed in the shop since.

Similar games →

Layers of Fear

Dread and tension

A psychological horror walking sim set in a mad painter's Victorian mansion that rearranges itself whenever you look away. Its shifting rooms and unsettling art slowly piece together a tragic tale of obsession and ruin.

Dead Secret

Dread and tension

A first-person horror mystery set in 1960s Kansas where you investigate a reclusive professor's death by searching his house and solving puzzles, while a threat closes in.

Phantasmagoria

Dread and tension

A 1990s point-and-click horror adventure with live-action video footage: as Adrienne you explore a sinister mansion and uncover its dark secret. Notorious for its graphic scenes and full-motion-video style.

Simulacra

Dread and tension

You dig through a missing woman's smartphone, reading messages, using apps and watching videos, to piece together a creepy mystery. A short, story-driven horror experience told through found-footage-style screen interaction.

The Black Mirror

Dread and tension

A gloomy gothic point-and-click adventure in which you play Samuel Gordon, exploring a sinister family estate to uncover the truth behind your grandfather's death and an ancient family curse.

Shinkansen 0

Dread and tension

Shinkansen 0 is a Japanese horror game that unfolds entirely aboard a bullet train. Its cramped, sealed-off setting builds a dense and uneasy atmosphere.

Gray Dawn

Dread and tension

A psychological horror thriller in which you play a priest accused of murdering an altar boy, wandering through nightmarish, religiously charged scenes. Exploration and puzzles drive a dark, story-focused narrative.

Layers of Fear 2

Dread and tension

A psychological horror walking-sim where you play an actor wandering an ocean liner whose film sets shift and warp around you. Its strengths are oppressive atmosphere, environmental puzzles and a surreal, cinematic story.

Feedback