The best 11 of 13 games

The best dark fantasy open-world games

Grim realms as far as the eye can see: open worlds full of danger, magic and decay.

The DNA of Dark fantasy open-world gamesSeven traits, averaged over the top 20 games. More story, less grind? Click to fine-tune.

Currently: nothing changed, the theme ranking

Mark games you enjoyed with “+ Select” and we’ll find what fits.

#1

Elden Ring

Very positive · 93 % positive

  • Interconnected level design
  • Boss fights as highlights
  • Challenging difficulty
from 53.99 €3 shops

Elden Ring

Where to buy

  • Gamesplanet* Best price Steam key 53.99 € 59.99 € −10 % Go to shop
  • Steam PC 59.99 € Go to shop
  • Amazon* Price in shop

* Affiliate link. Prices are synced regularly and may have changed in the shop since.

Similar games

#2

The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt

Overwhelmingly positive · 96 % positive

  • Dense, handcrafted world
  • Strong, story-driven narrative
  • Lore and world history
from 49.99 €3 shops

The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt

Where to buy

* Affiliate link. Prices are synced regularly and may have changed in the shop since.

Similar games

#3

Tainted Grail: The Fall of Avalon

Very positive · 87 % positive

  • Strong, story-driven narrative
  • Lore and world history
  • Melee combat with weapons or fists
from 43.99 €3 shops

Tainted Grail: The Fall of Avalon

Where to buy

* Affiliate link. Prices are synced regularly and may have changed in the shop since.

Similar games

#4

Gothic

Very positive · 91 % positive

  • Challenging difficulty
  • Strong, story-driven narrative
  • Melee combat with weapons or fists
from 19.99 €2 shops

Gothic

Where to buy

* Affiliate link. Prices are synced regularly and may have changed in the shop since.

Similar games

#5

The Blood of Dawnwalker

Very positive · 87 % positive

  • Strong, story-driven narrative
  • Choices with consequences
  • Lavish presentation
from 62.99 €3 shops

The Blood of Dawnwalker

Where to buy

  • Gamesplanet* Best price Steam key 62.99 € 69.99 € −10 % Go to shop
  • Steam PC 69.99 € Go to shop
  • Amazon* Price in shop

* Affiliate link. Prices are synced regularly and may have changed in the shop since.

Similar games

The full ranking

1 Elden Ring

Interconnected level design

2022 PC, PlayStation, Xbox, Steam Deck verified −10 % 59.99 € 53.99 € 93 % positive

A vast open world, demanding combat and countless secrets, from the creator of the Dark Souls series.

2 The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt

Dense, handcrafted world

2015 PC, PlayStation, Xbox, Nintendo Switch, Steam Deck verified 49.99 € 96 % positive

An open fantasy world with outstanding side quests and choices that have lasting consequences.

3 Tainted Grail: The Fall of Avalon

Strong, story-driven narrative

2025 PC, PlayStation, Xbox, Steam Deck verified 43.99 € 87 % positive

A grim first-person open-world RPG in the Skyrim mold that reimagines Arthurian legend as a decaying Avalon ravaged by plague and madness. Free exploration, flexible builds and quests with meaningful choices drive the experience.

4 Gothic

Challenging difficulty

2001 PC 19.99 € 91 % positive

As a nameless prisoner dumped into a mining colony sealed by a magic barrier, you claw your way up from nobody with no quest markers, joining one of three camps and learning skills only from trainers. Its harsh, believable world full of gruff characters and its unforgiving, clunky combat made it a cult classic.

5 The Blood of Dawnwalker

Strong, story-driven narrative

2026 PC, PlayStation, Xbox −10 % 69.99 € 62.99 € 87 % positive

A grim open-world action RPG set in medieval Europe, where Coen is a human by day and a vampire by night. That shift shapes how you fight and explore, and your choices steer the fight to save his family.

6 Mortal Online 2

Co-op or multiplayer

2022 PC 33.99 € 59 % positive

A first-person sandbox MMORPG set in a huge open world where full-loot PvP makes every trip risky. Broad freedom in skills and playstyle meets harsh, unforgiving consequences.

7 Middle-earth: Shadow of War

Lavish presentation

2017 PC, PlayStation, Xbox, Nintendo Switch 2, Steam Deck verified 39.99 € 88 % positive

As Talion you roam Mordor, dominating orc captains to build your own army and storm fortresses. The Nemesis System makes enemies remember you, rise in rank, and grow into personal rivals with their own stories.

8 Don't Starve

Distinctive, stylised art style

2013 PC, PlayStation, Xbox, Nintendo Switch, Steam Deck playable 8.19 € 96 % positive

A merciless survival game with a gothic, Tim Burton-esque hand-drawn style, where you scavenge, craft and fend off hunger, insanity and monsters in a procedurally generated wilderness. Death is permanent, but every run teaches you something new.

9 V Rising

Boss fights as highlights

2024 PC, PlayStation, Steam Deck verified −10 % 34.99 € 31.49 € 89 % positive

You play an awakened vampire who hunts for blood, avoids deadly sunlight and builds up your own castle. Fast top-down combat against memorable bosses drives your progression, whether you play solo or with others on online servers.

10 Conan Exiles

Sandbox with your own goals

2018 PC, PlayStation, Xbox, Steam Deck playable −10 % 39.99 € 35.99 € 78 % positive

A survival sandbox set in the brutal world of Conan the Barbarian: you build bases and whole cities, endure hunger, cold and enemies, and rise from a lowly exile to a mighty warrior. Playable solo, in co-op, or on persistent online servers with siege warfare.

11 Vampires: Bloodlord Rising

Strong character progression

2026 PC, PlayStation 19.99 € 71 % positive

Play as a vampire who builds a castle, runs a clan and spreads dominion across the land of Sangavia. An open-world action RPG with character development, a story and optional co-op.

What matters: Dark fantasy open-world games

Dark fantasy open-world games pair freedom to roam with a world that is rarely kind. You get ruined kingdoms, morally murky choices and monsters that punish carelessness. The appeal is atmosphere: exploring feels tense, and discoveries feel earned rather than handed to you.

The first thing to check is difficulty. Elden Ring and Gothic are both tagged Difficult, and both expect you to learn from mistakes, though Elden Ring is a soulslike action RPG built around exploration. If you prefer story and dialogue over punishment, The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt is tagged Story Rich with choices that matter, and Tainted Grail: The Fall of Avalon offers a mythology-driven action RPG with choices too. Next, decide between solo and shared play. V Rising and Conan Exiles are survival games tagged Co-op and Multiplayer, so they suit groups, while Mortal Online 2 is a PC multiplayer game tagged Difficult and Survival.

Pace and tone vary as well. Shadow of the Colossus is atmospheric and emotional rather than combat-heavy, and it is a good pick if you want a quieter journey. Check the platform list before buying, since Gothic is listed for PC only, while The Witcher 3 is listed for PC, PlayStation, Xbox and Nintendo Switch.

Frequently asked questions

What is the best dark fantasy open-world game for beginners?

The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt is a good starting point because it is story rich and built around choices. If you want something more challenging, Elden Ring rewards patient exploration.

Which dark fantasy open-world games can I play with friends?

V Rising and Conan Exiles are both tagged Co-op and Multiplayer, and both are survival games. Mortal Online 2 is also multiplayer, but it is PC only and tagged Difficult.

Are there dark fantasy open-world games with a calmer, more atmospheric feel?

Shadow of the Colossus is tagged Atmospheric and Emotional, with exploration and puzzle elements. Don't Starve is a hand-drawn survival game, though it is tagged Difficult.

Not quite your taste?

Give us a few favourite games and we’ll work out what really suits you. Not what everyone else is playing.

Personal recommendations

Feedback