Cover of Pony Island

Similar games

Games like Pony Island

2016PC, Steam Deck verified95 % positive4.99 €

A devil-run arcade machine turns out to be a meta puzzle-horror adventure that keeps breaking its own rules and toying with your expectations. With dark humor, hacking-style puzzles and clever twists, it is short but memorable.

Genre
Puzzle · Simulation
Playtime
about 3 h
Game mode
Single-player

What defines it

  • Puzzles and brain teasers
  • Dread and tension
  • Dark, serious atmosphere
  • Strong, story-driven narrative
Buy Pony Island

Where to buy

* Affiliate link. Prices are synced regularly and may have changed in the shop since.

Writing more about Pony Island …

The DNA of Pony IslandSeven traits the matches are based on. More story, less grind? Click to fine-tune.

Currently: nothing tweaked, pure Pony Island

10 games with a similar feel, best match first · How is this calculated?

#1 96%Match

Rusty Lake: Roots

Overwhelmingly positive · 97 % positive

  • Dread and tension
  • Puzzles and brain teasers
  • Dark, serious atmosphere
from 3.99 €2 shops

Rusty Lake: Roots

Where to buy

* Affiliate link. Prices are synced regularly and may have changed in the shop since.

Similar games

#2 95%Match

Rusty Lake Paradise

Overwhelmingly positive · 95 % positive

  • Puzzles and brain teasers
  • Dread and tension
  • Dark, serious atmosphere
from 3.99 €2 shops

Rusty Lake Paradise

Where to buy

* Affiliate link. Prices are synced regularly and may have changed in the shop since.

Similar games

#3 93%Match

Cube Escape: Paradox

Overwhelmingly positive · 97 % positive

  • Puzzles and brain teasers
  • Dark, serious atmosphere
  • Strong, story-driven narrative
free2 shops

Cube Escape: Paradox

Where to buy

* Affiliate link. Prices are synced regularly and may have changed in the shop since.

Similar games

#4 92%Match

Sanitarium

Very positive · 93 % positive

  • Dread and tension
  • Puzzles and brain teasers
  • Dark, serious atmosphere
from 10.25 €2 shops

Sanitarium

Where to buy

* Affiliate link. Prices are synced regularly and may have changed in the shop since.

Similar games

#5 91%Match

Rusty Lake Hotel

Overwhelmingly positive · 96 % positive

  • Puzzles and brain teasers
  • Dread and tension
  • Dark, serious atmosphere
from 1.99 €2 shops

Rusty Lake Hotel

Where to buy

* Affiliate link. Prices are synced regularly and may have changed in the shop since.

Similar games

Places 6–10

Just missed the podium

  1. 6. The White Door

    Puzzles and brain teasers

  2. 7. Sally Face

    Dread and tension

  3. 8. Edna & Harvey: Harvey's New Eyes

    Puzzles and brain teasers

  4. 9. Cube Escape: The Mill

    Puzzles and brain teasers

  5. 10. Cube Escape: Case 23

    Puzzles and brain teasers

In short: Games like Pony Island

Each of these 10 games has a piece of what makes Pony Island tick. What exactly is right there on the game. No black box, promise.

Feedback